| 年度 | メトロポリタンH |
ブルックリンH* |
サバーバンH** |
カーターH |
ヴォスバーグS*3 |
| 1884 | - | - | Gen Monroe | - | - |
| 1885 | - | - | Pontiac | - | - |
| 1886 | - | - | Troubadour | - | - |
| 1887 | - | Dry Monopole | Errus | - | - |
| 1888 | - | The Bard | Elkwood | - | - |
| 1889 | - | Exile | Raceland | - | - |
| 1890 | - | Castaway | Salvator | - | - |
| 1891 | Tristan | Tenny | Loantaka | - | - |
| 1892 | Pessaro | Judge Morrow | Montana | - | - |
| 1893 | Charade | Diablo | Lowlander | - | - |
| 1894 | Ramapo | Dr. Rice | Ramapo | - | - |
| 1895 | - | Hornpipe | Lazzarone | Charade | - |
| 1896 | Counter Tenor | Sir Walter | Henry of Navarre | Deerslayer | - |
| 1897 | Voter | Howard Mann | Ben Brush | Premier | - |
| 1898 | Bowling Brook | Ornament | Tillo | The Manxman | - |
| 1899 | Filigrane | Banastar | Imp | Duke of Middleburg | - |
| 1900 | Ethelbert | Kinley Mack | Kinley Mack | Box | - |
| 年度 | メトロポリタンH |
ブルックリンH* |
サバーバンH** |
カーターH |
ヴォスバーグS*3 |
| 1901 | Banastar | Conroy | Alcedo | Motley | - |
| 1902 | Arsenal | Reina | Gold Heels | Ethics | - |
| 1903 | Gunfire | Irish Lad | Africander | Ahumada | - |
| 1904 | Irish Lad | - | Hermis | Beldame | - |
| 1905 | Sysonby Race King |
Delhi | Beldame | Ormonde's Right | - |
| 1906 | Grapple | Tokalon | Go Between | Roseben | - |
| 1907 | Glorifier | Superman | Nealon | Glorified | - |
| 1908 | Jack Atkin | Celt | Ballot | Jack Atkin | - |
| 1909 | King James | King James | Fitz Herbert | - | - |
| 1910 | Fashion Plate | Fitz Herbert | Olambala | Gretna Greenz | - |
| 1911 | - | - | - | - | - |
| 1912 | - | - | - | - | - |
| 1913 | Whisk Broom | Whisk Broon | Whisk Broom | - | - |
| 1914 | Buskin | Buckhorn | - | Roamer | - |
| 1915 | Stomboli | Tartar | Stromboli | Phosphor | - |
| 1916 | The Finn | Friar Rock | Friar Rock | Trial by Jury | - |
| 1917 | Ormsdale | Borrow | Boots | Old Rosebud | - |
| 1918 | Trompe La Mort | Cudgel | Johren | Old Koenig | - |
| 1919 | Lanius | Eternal | Corn Tassel | Naturalist | - |
| 1920 | Wildair | Cirrus | Paul Jones | Audacious | - |
| 1921 | Mad Hatter | Grey Lag | Audacious | Audacious | - |
| 1922 | Mad Hatter | Exterminator | Captain Alcock | Knobbie | - |
| 1923 | Grey Lag | Little Chief | Grey Lag | Little Colt | - |
| 1924 | Laurano | Hephaistos | Mad Hatter | Sarazen | - |
| 1925 | Sting | Mad Play | Sting | Silver Fox | - |
| 1926 | Sarazen | Single Foot | Crusader | Macaw Nedana |
- |
| 1927 | Black Maria | Peanuts | Crusader | Happy Argo | - |
| 1928 | Nimba | Black Panther | Dolan | Osmand | - |
| 1929 | Petee-Wrack | Light Carbine | Bateau | Osmand | - |
| 1930 | Jack High | Sortie | Pette-Wrack | Flying Heels | - |
| 1931 | Questionnaire | Questionnaire | Mokatam | Flying Heels | - |
| 1932 | Equipoise | Blenheim | White Clover | Happy Scot | - |
| 1933 | Equipoise | Dark Secret | Equipoise | - | - |
| 1934 | Mr. Khayyam | Discovery | Ladysman | - | - |
| 1935 | King Saxon | Discovery | Head Play | King Saxon | - |
| 1936 | Good Harvest | Discovery | Friethorn | Clang | - |
| 1937 | Snark | Seabiscuit | Aneroid | Aneroid | - |
| 1938 | Danger Point | The Chief | Snark | Airflame | - |
| 1939 | Knickerbocker | Cravat | Cravat | Fighting Fox | - |
| 1940 | Third Degree | Isolater | Eight Thirty | He Did | Joe Schenck |
| 1941 | Eight Thirty | Fenelon | Your Chance | Parasang | Joe Schenck |
| 1942 | Attention | Whirlaway | Market Wise | Doublrab | Parasang |
| 1943 | Devil Diver | Devil Diver | Don Bingo | Devil Diver | Wait A Bit |
| 1944 | Devil Diver | Four Freedoms | Aletern | Bossuet Wait a Bit Browni |
Paperboy Cassis |
| 1945 | Devil Diver | Stymie | Devil Diver | Apache | Buzfuz |
| 1946 | Gallorette | Gallorette | Armed | Flood Town | Coincidence |
| 1947 | Stymie | Assault | Assault | Rippey | With Pleasure |
| 1948 | Stymie | Conniver | Harmonica | Gallorette | Colosal |
| 1949 | Loser Weeper | Assault | Vulcan's Forge | Better Self | Loser Weeper |
| 1950 | Greek Ship | My Reauest | Loser Weeper | Guillotine | Tea-Maker |
| 年度 | メトロポリタンH |
ブルックリンH* |
サバーバンH** |
カーターH |
ヴォスバーグS*3 |
| 1951 | Casemate | Palestinian | Busanda | Arise | War King |
| 1952 | Mameluke | Crafty Admiral | One Hitter | Northern Star | Parading Lady |
| 1953 | Tom Fool | Tom Fool | Tom Fool | Tom Fool | Indian Land |
| 1954 | Native Dancer | Invigorator | Straight Face | White Skies | Joe Jones |
| 1955 | High Gun | High Gun | Helioscope | Bobby Brocato | Nance`s Lad |
| 1956 | Midafternon | Dedicate | Nashua | Red Hannigan | Summer Tan |
| 1957 | Traffic Judge | Portersville | Traffic Judge | Portersville | Bold Ruler |
| 1958 | Gallant Man | Cohoes | Bold Ruler | Bold Ruler | Tick Tock |
| 1959 | Sword Dancer | Babu | Bald Eagle | Jimmer | Rick City |
| 1960 | Bald Eagle | On-and-On | Sword Dancer | Yes You Will | Mail Order |
| 1961 | Kelso | Kelso | Kelso | Chief of Chiefs | Gyro |
| 1962 | Carry Back | Beau Purple | Beau Purple | Merry Ruler | Commend |
| 1963 | Cyrano | Cyrano | Kelso | Admiral's Voyage | Ornamento |
| 1964 | Olden Times | Gun Bow | Iron Peg | Ahoy | Affectionately |
| 1965 | Gun Bow | Pia Star | Pia Star | Viking Spirit | R. Thomas |
| 1966 | Bold Lad | Buckpasser | Buffle | Davis | Gallant Romeo |
| 1967 | Buckpasser | Handsome Boy | Buckpasser | Tumiga | Dr. Fager |
| 1968 | In Reality | Damascus | Dr. Fager | In Reality | Dr. Fager |
| 1969 | Arts and Letters | Nodouble | Mr. Right | Promise | Ta Wee |
| 1970 | Nodouble | Dewan | Barometer | Tyrant | Best Turn |
| 1971 | Tunex | Never Bow | Twice Worthy | Native Royalty | Duck Dance |
| 1972 | Executioner | Key to the Mint | Hitchcock | Leematt | Triple Bend |
| 1973 | Tentam | Riva Ridge | Key to the Mint | King's Bishop | Aljamin |
| 1974 | Arbees Boy | Forego | True Knight | Forego | Forego |
| 1975 | Gold and Myrrh | Forego | Forego | Forego | No Bias |
| 1976 | Forego | Forego | Foolish Pleasure | Due Diligence | My Juliet(f) |
| 1977 | Forego | Great Contractor | Quiet Little Table | D1:Quiet Little Table D1:Gentle King D2:Soy Numero Uno |
Affiliate |
| 1978 | Cox's Ridge | Nasty and Bold | Upper Nile | D1:Pumpkin Moonshine D2:Jaipur's Gem |
Dr. Patches |
| 1979 | State Dinner | The Liberal Member | State Dinner | Star de Naskra | General Assembly |
| 1980 | Czaravich | Winter's Tale | Winter's Tale | Czaravich | Plugged Nickle |
| 1981 | Fappiano | Hechizado | Temperence Hill | Amber Pass | Guilty Conscience |
| 1982 | Conquistador Cielo | Silver Supreme | Silver Buck | Pass the Tab | Engine One |
| 1983 | Star Choice | Highland Blade | Winter's Tale | Vittorioso | A Phenomenon |
| 1984 | Fit to Fight | Fit to Fight | Fit to Fight | Bet Big | Track Barron |
| 1985 | Forzando | Bounding Basque | Vanlandingham | Mt. Livermore | Another Reef |
| 1986 | Garthorn | Little Missouri | Roo Art | Love That Mac | King's Swan |
| 1987 | Gulch | Waquoit | Broad Brush | Pine Tree Lane | Groovy |
| 1988 | Gulch | Waquoit | Personal Flag | Gulch | Mining |
| 1989 | Proper Reality | Forever Silver | Dancing Spree | On the Line | Sewickley |
| 1990 | Criminal Type | Montubio | Easy Goer | Dancing Spree | Sewickley |
| 1991 | In Excess | Timely Warning | In Excess | Housebuster | Housebuster |
| 1992 | Dixie Brass | Chief Honcho | Pleasant Tap | Rubiano | Rubiano |
| 1993 | Ibero | Living Vicariously | Devil His Due | Alydeed | Birdonthewire |
| 1994 | Holy Bull | Devil His Due | Devil His Due | Virginia Rapids | Harlan |
| 1995 | You and I | You and I | Key Contender | Lite the Fuse | Not Surprising |
| 1996 | Honour and Glory | Wekiva Springs | Wekiva Springs | Lite the Fuse | Langfuhr |
| 1997 | Langfuhr | Formal Gold | Skip Away | Langfuhr | Victor Cooley |
| 1998 | Wild Rush | Subordination | Frisk Me Now | Wild Rush | Affirmed Success |
| 1999 | Sir Bear | Running Stag | Behrens | Artax | Artax |
| 2000 | Yankee Victor | Lemon Drop Kid | Lemon Drop Kid | Brutally Frank | Trippi |
| 年度 | メトロポリタンH |
ブルックリンH* |
サバーバンH** |
カーターH |
ヴォスバーグS*3 |
| 2001 | Exciting Story | Albert the Great | Albert the Great | Peeping Tom | Left Bank |
| 2002 | Swept Overboard | Seeking Daylight | E Dubai | Affirmed Success | Bonapaw |
| 2003 | Aldebaran | Iron Deputy | Mineshaft | Congaree | Ghostzapper |
| 2004 | Pico Central | Seattle Fitz | Peace Rules | Pico Central | Pico Central |
| 2005 | Ghostzapper | Limehouse | Offlee Wild | Forest Danger | Taste of Paradise |
| 2006 | Silver Train | Wanderin Boy | Invasor | Bishop Court Hill | Henny Hughes |
| 2007 | Corinthian | Any Given Saturday | Political Force | Silver Wagon | Fabulous Strike |
| 2008 | Divine Park | Delosvientos | Frost Giant | Bustin Stones | Black Seventeen |
| 2009 | Bribon | Eldaafer | Dry Martini | Kodiak Kowboy | Kodiak Kowboy |
| 2010 | Quality Road | Alcomo | Haynesfield | Warrior's Reward | Girolamo |
| 2011 | Tizway | Birdrun | Flat Out | Morning Line | Giant Ryan |
| 2012 | Shackleford | Redeemed | Mucho Macho Man | Jackson Bend | The Lumber Guy |
| 2013 | Sahara Sky | Calidoscopio | Flat Out | Swagger Jack | Privete Zone |
| 2014 | Palace Malice | Norumbega | Zivo | Dads Caps | Private Zone |
| 2015 | Honor Code | Coach Inge | Effinex | Dads Caps | Rock Fall |
| 2016 | Frosted | Shaman Ghost | Effinex | Salutos Amigos | Joking |
| 2017 |
*ブルックリンH：1887-2013 ブルックリン招待S：2014-
**サバーバンH：1884-2013, 2015 サバーバンS：2014
*3ヴォスバーグH：1940-78 ヴォスバーグS：1979-2010, 14 ヴォスバーグ招待S：2011-13